B: Concerns about day labor centers
Are they legal?
Residents of Jupiter and others who oppose El Sol believe that the hiring of day laborers violates federal law making it illegal to hire, fire, or recruit for payment any person who is unauthorized to work in the U.S.. Federal law also requires employers to verify a worker's documents, ensuring that s/he is a documented worker.
However, the people at El Sol, and other day labor centers around the country, assert that they are violating no laws. They cite an exception, allowed by federal law, which allows private individuals and homeowners to hire independent contractors or temporary domestic workers for short time periods without violating federal law. Employers are not required to verify the papers of workers they hire as independent contractors.
| Some workers miss opportunities to work because of community concerns over day labor legality. |
Magnets?
Aside from concerns about legality, some protesters opposed to El Sol say that the center could serve as a magnet for undocumented workers, encouraging more undocumented immigrants to cross the border and thus exacerbate the immigrant problem. However, according to a 2006 report by UCLA's Center for the Study of Urban Poverty, 83% of day laborers learned of day labor centers only after migrating to the U.S., and therefore the center could not have served as an incentive to migrate.
http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/issr/csup/uploaded_files/Natl_DayLabor-On_the_Corner1.pdf